As a writer, can you recognize when something you’ve written doesn’t work?
In Unless It Moves the Human Heart: The Craft and Art of Writing, Roger Rosenblatt says:
Good writers always know when something is wrong with a piece. They may kid themselves for a while, but the mistake eats at them until they have no choice but to act.
Does Rosenblatt’s opinion ring true to you?
I have mixed feelings about it.
I think I can recognize when my work is blatantly “off.” But I’m not so sure about smaller things. That’s why I’m always open to getting a second opinion on my work. For example, my writing group’s feedback on Financial Blogging: How to Write Powerful Posts That Attract Clients was very helpful. I also sometimes use software to read things out loud to myself. As I said in “Why I love Adobe Acrobat Pro for proofreading,” I hear problems that I couldn’t see.
What about you? Can you tell when something is wrong with your writing?